If you’re planning an outdoor project—maybe a new deck, a fresh fence, or even some siding—you’ve probably come across two popular wood options: Western Red Cedar (WRC) and Alaska Yellow Cedar (AYC). Both are fantastic choices, known for their durability and natural beauty, but they each have their own strengths. So, how do you decide which one is best for your home improvement project? Let’s break it down in a way that makes sense for DIYers and homeowners like you.
What Do They Look Like?
Western Red Cedar has that classic, warm, reddish-brown color—think cozy mountain cabin vibes. It can range from a light honey tone to a deep reddish hue, giving decks and fences a naturally rich appearance. Over time, if left untreated, it ages to a silvery-gray, which can add a nice rustic charm.
Alaska Yellow Cedar, on the other hand, is more of a pale yellow to golden tone and has a very uniform color. It’s got a smooth and fine grain, making it look a bit more polished and refined. Just like Western Red Cedar, it will turn silver-gray if left exposed to the elements.
Which One Lasts Longer?
Both woods are naturally resistant to rot, decay, and pesky insects, making them great for outdoor projects.
- Western Red Cedar has natural oils and tannins that help protect it from moisture and fungal growth. That’s why it’s a go-to choice for decking, fencing, and siding—especially in damp climates.
- Alaska Yellow Cedar is actually not a true cedar but part of the cypress family. It’s denser and harder than Western Red Cedar, meaning it’s even more durable. This makes it a top pick for heavy-duty projects like boat building, bridge decking, and high-traffic areas.
Which One is Easier to Work With?
- Western Red Cedar is lightweight and easy to cut, nail, and screw, making it super DIY-friendly. Plus, it takes stain and finishes really well, so you can customize the look however you want.
- Alaska Yellow Cedar is harder and denser, so while it’s more durable, it can be trickier to work with—especially if you’re using basic tools. But on the plus side, its fine grain makes it perfect for detailed woodworking projects, and it holds paint and stains beautifully.
Is One More Eco-Friendly?
Both woods are sustainably harvested, especially when sourced from responsibly managed forests.
- Western Red Cedar mainly comes from the Pacific Northwest (think British Columbia and the U.S. West Coast). Many suppliers follow sustainable forestry practices to keep these forests healthy.
- Alaska Yellow Cedar grows in coastal Alaska and British Columbia, but it takes longer to mature, making it a bit rarer. However, its long lifespan helps offset its slow growth, since you won’t need to replace it as often.
At Cedar Country Lumber, we source both Western Red Cedar and Alaska Yellow Cedar directly from mills in the Pacific Northwest and British Columbia. We ensure that our products come from sustainable and high-quality sources so you get the best materials for your project. Plus, we deliver locally and ship nationwide, making it easy to get the perfect cedar for your build no matter where you are!
How Do They Compare in Price?
Cost is always a big factor when choosing materials.
- Western Red Cedar is more widely available and comes in different grades, from high-end, clear boards to more rustic, knotty options. This means you can usually find something that fits your budget.
- Alaska Yellow Cedar is a bit pricier because it’s denser and less abundant. But if you need a super-durable wood that can handle tough conditions, it might be worth the extra investment.
Best Uses for Each Wood Type
So, which one should you pick? Here’s a quick breakdown of the best uses for each.
Western Red Cedar Is Great For:
✔️ Decking – Warm, beautiful, and naturally weather-resistant. ✔️ Siding – Adds character and provides insulation. ✔️ Fencing – Lightweight and easy to install. ✔️ Pergolas & Outdoor Structures – Enhances patios and gardens with natural charm. ✔️ Shingles & Roofing – A classic choice for traditional homes.
Alaska Yellow Cedar Works Best For:
✔️ Boat Building – Super moisture-resistant, ideal for marine projects. ✔️ Bridge Decking & Heavy-Duty Builds – Handles wear and tear like a champ. ✔️ Outdoor Furniture – Long-lasting and resistant to weathering. ✔️ Carvings & Millwork – Fine grain makes it perfect for detailed work. ✔️ Roof Shakes & Shingles – Holds up incredibly well in extreme weather.
So, Which One Should You Choose?
It really depends on what you’re looking for.
- Go with Western Red Cedar if you want something that’s beautiful, easy to work with, and cost-effective. It’s perfect for most standard outdoor projects like decking, fencing, and siding.
- Choose Alaska Yellow Cedar if you need something tougher and longer-lasting, especially for high-traffic or heavy-duty projects. It’s a great option if you’re willing to invest a little more upfront for longevity.
Both types of cedar offer stunning natural beauty and excellent performance, so you really can’t go wrong. Hopefully, this breakdown helps you decide which one is the best fit for your next project. Need help sourcing your cedar? Cedar Country Lumber has you covered—we deliver locally and ship nationwide! Happy building!